Ballot for charter-ietf-spring
Block
Yes
No Objection
Abstain
No Record
Summary: Has a BLOCK. Has enough positions to pass once BLOCK positions are resolved.
Ballot question: "Is this charter ready for external review?"
(3) What is the new work to be done and what are the bounds? The charter seems extremely open-ended. With this new charter text and absence of milestones, it isn’t clear what new work the WG will pursue or even what the bounds are to judge that a given topic is in/out of scope (beyond being SR related). The primary bounding text I see is "The SPRING WG is responsible for defining new applications for, and specifying extensions to, Segment Routing technologies. It also serves as a forum to discuss the operational aspects of deploying and managing SR-MPLS networks." What is an example of an application the WG will work on right now? What are the extensions? Am I correct in assuming there is a maintenance role for extensions? What are the first several that need to be worked on known now to motivate this WG? Can those be added as milestones? When is the WG “done”? Can this need for latitude be further explained?
Thank you to Alvaro Retana for his explanation on trust domains. Thank you for the revision which clarified how new work would be accepted.
I also agree with Roman/Gunter's blocks and John's comments. Para 2: I did find the discussion of working groups involved, data plane, management plane verbiage to be difficult to follow. At the very least, there should be guardrails or milestones (or both).
Thank you for addressing my concern with the line "The SPRING WG will manage its specific work items based on WG engagement and successful adoption."
Thanks for addressing one of my previous BLOCK point and the non-blocking COMMENT. After discussions with the SPRING WG chairs, I am balloting ABSTAIN because the current charter is also open (i.e., the scope is mostly unlimited) :-( , so there is no ground to justify a BLOCK for the proposed draft charter, whose scope is also open. Happy to change my ballot to a YES if the WG scope becomes more defined. Side note: I am trusting the current SPRING WG chairs and AD for applying common sense during adoption calls & WGLC.
Thanks for updating the charter based on the comments/feedbackc. The current charter addresses my blocking comments well.
This sentence makes my brain hurt, simply because the syntax requires way too much parsing: Any modification of -or extension to- existing architectures, data planes, or control or management plane protocols should be carried out in the WGs responsible for the architecture, data plane, or control or management plane protocol being modified and in coordination with the SPRING WG, but may be done in SPRING WG after agreement with all the relevant WG chairs and responsible Area Directors. (Also, the "-or extension to-" thing is just wrong, turn those dashes into commas, if that text is kept. There are some definite articles missing and stuff, too.) I don't have a fantastic rewrite to offer, but a first attempt might be to break it into several smaller sentences, as in, Any modification of, or extension to, existing architectures, data planes, or control or management plane protocols should be carried out in the WGs responsible for the same. The responsible WG should coordinate with the SPRING WG. Alternatively, the work may be done in the SPRING WG after agreement with all the relevant WG chairs and responsible Area Directors. I'll be interested in the response to Roman's BLOCK, and I want to echo his implicit "why aren't any milestones listed?"
I support Roman's BLOCK and John's comments.
| 脖子为什么会痒 | 肛门胀痛什么原因 | 身上总是痒是什么原因 | 草酸对人体有什么危害 | 626什么星座 |
| 上嘴唇上有痣代表什么 | sm什么意思 | 傻人有傻福什么意思 | 什么是星座 | 万寿菊什么时候开花 |
| 1月17号什么星座 | 什么叫护理 | 怀孕什么水果不能吃 | 精分是什么 | 企鹅是什么动物 |
| 孕妇做唐筛是检查什么 | 梦见自己给自己理发是什么意思 | prada是什么品牌 | 见龙在田什么意思 | 雅号是什么意思 |
| 香菇配什么菜好吃hcv7jop9ns6r.cn | 大势至菩萨代表什么hcv8jop8ns8r.cn | 00年属龙的是什么命bfb118.com | 白菜什么时候播种hcv7jop6ns3r.cn | 什么河没有水hcv8jop6ns8r.cn |
| 嘴唇正常颜色是什么样hcv9jop3ns8r.cn | 毛躁是什么意思helloaicloud.com | 脚底发黄是什么原因hcv8jop0ns7r.cn | 投诉快递打什么电话hcv9jop2ns8r.cn | 早上头晕是什么原因hcv7jop9ns2r.cn |
| 治未病是什么意思hcv8jop0ns1r.cn | 血燥是什么意思hcv8jop3ns8r.cn | 活学活用是什么意思hcv9jop0ns8r.cn | 左卵巢内囊性结构什么意思hcv9jop3ns6r.cn | inf是什么意思hcv9jop0ns1r.cn |
| 尿液有泡沫是什么原因hcv8jop8ns8r.cn | 土耳其是什么人种hcv7jop9ns5r.cn | 什么的身影hcv9jop3ns3r.cn | 什么头什么节hcv9jop1ns6r.cn | 薄熙来为什么被抓hcv8jop7ns9r.cn |